Jan 12

Print this Post

Turn Your Old Magic & Pokemon Cards Into Cash!

Got any old gaming cards lying around the house? Bring them on into The Fantastic Store and turn those cards into cash! Check out our rates below:


  • For any Common, Uncommon, Rare, or Trainer cards in Near-Mint to Mint condition, we’re currently paying $.05/Card in cash ($.06/Card in store credit), a rate you won’t find any where else.
  • For Reverse Holos/Holos, we’re currently paying $.20/Card in cash OR $.25/Card in store credit!
  • We’re also looking for Ultra Rare, Secret Rare, EXs, and Full Arts – bring them in and we’ll make you a cash offer.
  • While they’re definitely necessary to the game, we’re currently not taking in basic Energy Cards.
  • From here on out, we are only accepting in-store submissions of 2,000 cards or less per person per week. We will NOT be accepting any more mail-in submissions!

In order to save time when you get here, please prepare your trade-in by doing the following:

  • Remove all cards from any binders, protective sleeves, etc.
  • Have all of your cards facing the same direction.
  • Please make sure cards are transported securely in order to prevent any incidental damage; rubber bands are a card’s worst nightmare.

Image result for pokemon cards

Magic: The Gathering:

We now have an online buylist tool that’ll enable you to research exactly how much you can expect for your cards right from your couch!

Image result for magic the gathering cards

Check out our online buylist here!


Permanent link to this article: http://www.thefantasticstore.com/turn-your-old-magic-pokemon-cards-into-cash/